← Back to PlanUnderstanding Phase

1 of 20

Introduction

Is Utilitarianism a Convincing Moral Theory?

  • Utilitarianism is a normative ethical theory holding that the right action is that which maximises utility, understood as the overall good produced by an action's consequences
  • It is consequentialist: the rightness of an action depends entirely on its consequences, not on the nature of the action itself or the intentions of the agent
  • It is hedonistic in its classical forms: Bentham's act utilitarianism holds that utility is happiness, understood as pleasure and the absence of pain; Mill's qualitative utilitarianism refines this by distinguishing higher intellectual pleasures from lower bodily ones; preference utilitarianism, advanced by Singer, replaces happiness with preference-satisfaction as the relevant good
  • The theory also comes in act and rule forms: act utilitarianism demands we apply the utility principle to individual actions; rule utilitarianism demands we follow rules whose general acceptance maximises utility
  • I will consider three objections in order of cruciality: that utilitarianism faces irresolvable problems of calculation; that Mill's proof of the greatest happiness principle fails and hedonism with it; and that consequentialism as a criterion of rightness is fundamentally mistaken, because it evaluates states of affairs rather than actions and judges agents by outcomes outside their control. The first is a practical problem that rule utilitarianism largely solves; the second attacks the hedonistic foundation, motivating a move to preference utilitarianism; the third attacks what every form of utilitarianism shares and cannot be escaped. I will argue that utilitarianism is not a convincing moral theory